Homeowners Associations (HOAs) started as a way for neighbors to work together and keep property values up. The idea was that if everyone follows basic rules (like not painting your house neon pink), the whole neighborhood stays nice and homes are worth a bit more.
Studies show homes in HOA neighborhoods are usually worth 5-6% more than similar homes without one. That’s the main selling point: you pay fees and follow rules, but your house gains value.
But things have changed a lot. Today, if you’re buying a new home (especially built in recent years), there’s a good chance it has to be part of an HOA — around 65-70% of new single-family homes in 2024 were built with one. That means you often don’t get a real choice. You’re basically locked in.
The old problem was sometimes a grumpy neighbor or retiree on the board nitpicking things like your mailbox color or holiday decorations. Now, it’s becoming more automatic and strict. Many HOAs use special software that tracks every little rule break — like a faded fence or wrong trash can placement — logs it, sends notices, and charges fines with less human forgiveness. It’s less about personal grudges and more about cold, consistent enforcement.
The value boost (that 5-6%) starts to feel like a price you pay for less freedom in your own home. You get the premium, but in exchange, your house is treated more like a shared community asset than your personal space. Rules can change with new boards or software updates, and you’re stuck with them.
Some states are pushing back. In California, a 2025 law (AB 130) caps most fines at $100 per violation (except serious safety issues) and gives homeowners more chances to fix things before paying. Other places, like Michigan and Illinois, had to pass specific laws just to stop HOAs from banning solar panels or natural/native plants in yards. The fact that lawmakers had to step in to let people add solar power or grow wildflowers shows how far the control has gone.
In the end, the real cost isn’t just the occasional fine — it’s that “home” feels less like your own private refuge and more like a monitored spot in a managed community. What began as a helpful agreement between neighbors has turned into a layer of private rules that can make everyday choices (like your yard or lights) feel restricted.
cafebedouin.org 